http://cheerfulghost.com/WhiteboySlim/events/71/games-club-knights-of-the-old-republic
Kotorbox
This event is over
Start:
End:
happening all day
8 spots left

Come play through Kotor with the CG community! Feel free to post your thoughts about the game, your character builds, team composition, any mods you used, and anything else you want to talk about! Given how old this game is I'm not really concerned about spoilers, but keep in mind some of us might not have played the game before so try to avoid the BIG spoilers (you know what I'm talking about!) until we get closer to the end of the month when hopefully everyone will be hitting the end of the game. :)
You will need to sign in to join this event.

Users signed up:

Star unselected
Photo WhiteboySlim wrote on 02/09/2015 at 06:51pm
Alright, I'll get this discussion started. I've played through the game probably 4 or 5 times before, but it's been awhile. I decided to start over after I realized I picked a couple feats on my character I didn't want because I had forgotten what everything was, lol. Now on my second character, I just wrapped up everything on Taris and landed on Dantooine.

I've decided to go as a Scout and I'm focusing on dual wielding melee (later I'll use a double-bladed light saber) weapons. As far as skills go, I'm just trying to keep Persuasion and Awareness maxed, and putting any extra points into Computer or Demolition. One thing I like about the Scout class is you get the Implant feats for free, and I find the implants are pretty useful. :)

I'm not sure what characters I'm going to use in my part. I usually use Bastilla and either Carth or HK-47 because he's hilarious. I want to use different characters this time around though. Any recommendations from anyone?

On a side note, this is my first time playing this on PC as I own it on Xbox also. I was surprised that this game doesn't have any kind of controller support what-so-ever. The keyboard/mouse controls are fine, but I really was hoping to use my Xbox 360 controller. I was also annoyed to find there was a pretty bad bug in the game that made the main character immobile, which required me to switch to my second character in order to move around. This one I Googled and it looks like it is a problem with one of the graphics settings. Once I turned ON v-sync the issue seems to have gone away.
Photo WhiteboySlim wrote on 02/09/2015 at 06:56pm
Oh, and I also had forgotten how whiney Carth is in the beggining of the game. Seriously dude, I get it, you have trust issues, but please shut up about them. :P
74c46166202d8f4ef1a74e511e278b05.png?d=http%3a%2f%2fcheerfulghost.com%2fassets%2favatars%2fheadphone cheerful ghost Travis wrote on 02/09/2015 at 10:12pm
If anyone has trouble getting this older game going on newer hardware:

http://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=362478411
D954c245b9b17eb70ef2a7f547d392a9d148df97 full jdodson wrote on 02/10/2015 at 01:47am
OK so I installed this and started playing it. A few thoughts.

The UI doesn't really hold up well and seems a bit clunky. I don't think this is simply because it's an older game, I think the PC menus are designed poorly. Does it look or operate better on XBox?

I am playing it on my Mac and it's a bit laggy. It's not terrible, but i'd expect a pretty butter smooth experience from such an old game on really new hardware.

That said, I have enjoyed the game so far and understand why people herald it as the best Star Wars game. It seems like BioWare were real fans of the series and did what they could to make it authentic. One thing that I noticed was that in the game there are "Sith Troopers" and "Sith Warriors." This makes sense and if EP IV-VI is your guide that would be how i'd have done it.

Oh and WBS i'd go a bit easy on Carth, his planet was firebombed into submission by the Sith and takes some personal responsibility for it. All in all, his regret seems understandable.
D954c245b9b17eb70ef2a7f547d392a9d148df97 full jdodson wrote on 02/10/2015 at 01:48am
That said, I do have some questions and am not sure how to proceed because I am not sure what kind of RPG this is.

Should I be buying armor and weapon upgrades or stick to what drops?
D954c245b9b17eb70ef2a7f547d392a9d148df97 full jdodson wrote on 02/10/2015 at 02:12am
OK so I just installed the PC version and transferred over my Mac save. Apparently I can't run everything on the highest setting on a high resolution on the Mac, the game suffers. Still strange for such an old game.
D954c245b9b17eb70ef2a7f547d392a9d148df97 full jdodson wrote on 02/10/2015 at 02:27am
A few other things I've noted in this game.

Only Jedi use Lightsabers but everyone and everyone uses swords. Find this amusing.
Photo WhiteboySlim wrote on 02/10/2015 at 04:30am
Yeah I noticed it's not quite "butter smooth" on my modern PC also. The UI is a bit clunky, and it's almost the exact same menu as the Xbox version. Actually I think I had an easier time playing on Xbox, which is another reason I wish there was controller support. Still, it's a very minor difference and it wasn't hard to transition to keyboard and mouse.
D954c245b9b17eb70ef2a7f547d392a9d148df97 full jdodson wrote on 02/10/2015 at 04:34am
After playing on the PC I've noticed things are much better.
74c46166202d8f4ef1a74e511e278b05.png?d=http%3a%2f%2fcheerfulghost.com%2fassets%2favatars%2fheadphone cheerful ghost Travis wrote on 02/10/2015 at 04:51am
The controls don't feel right at all with a keyboard and mouse. It's disconcerting. I've never played a game that controls like it, and I can't seem to get my muscle memory to adapt.
D954c245b9b17eb70ef2a7f547d392a9d148df97 full jdodson wrote on 02/10/2015 at 05:23am
I use WASD to move around and click on things to make it work. It's kind of like Neverwinter Nights and I don't mind it but you can't jump or anything, which is strange.

Games from this era of BioWare were all turn based RPGs. It looks like NWN, Jade Empire and KOTOR play similarly to this.
D954c245b9b17eb70ef2a7f547d392a9d148df97 full jdodson wrote on 02/10/2015 at 05:24am
Oh and if you are wondering why the score is so great, it's because it was written by Jeremy Soule.
Photo WhiteboySlim wrote on 02/10/2015 at 05:41pm
Jon: Sorry I didn't see your question about armor/weapons. Ummm, money is kinda hard to come by in this game, and if you explore around on Taris you'll probably find plenty of armor and weapons to get you by for now. Eventually you'll want to buy better gear for your team though. Also keep an eye out for gear that can be upgraded.
D5d9a3b8d3e196c84da0672a7cec635f.png?d=http%3a%2f%2fcheerfulghost.com%2fassets%2favatars%2fheadphone cheerful ghost rettisawesome wrote on 02/10/2015 at 07:48pm
Honestly. I've played this game through more than 20 times. And i cant remember buying anything. sometimes id buy stimpacks. or other consumables. i think there are a few good items you can buy. but they will be quickly replaced with other stuff you find.

also i flipped this game on my xbox just to remember. and crap. still great. UI is fine on xbox. only played on pc once but dont remember an issue. also yes this game is basically a starwars version of Dungeons and Dragons. It directly ports the famous D20 system. even right down to the attributes and feats system.

still a great game. still a 10/10.

also epic stroyline. nothing has made me feel more BA than this ending.
I'll post more as a i get more into it.
D5d9a3b8d3e196c84da0672a7cec635f.png?d=http%3a%2f%2fcheerfulghost.com%2fassets%2favatars%2fheadphone cheerful ghost rettisawesome wrote on 02/10/2015 at 07:53pm
Oh WBS- i've always gotten a few chuckles playing with t3-m4 and it kind of makes me feel like luke skywalker at times, bickering with artoo. canderous was always my favorite though i think. hearing his stories about the mandolorian war is so awesome (plus he becomes mandalore which is BA). i also like jolee as he is the quigon jinn of this game.
D954c245b9b17eb70ef2a7f547d392a9d148df97 full jdodson wrote on 02/10/2015 at 08:15pm
The game tone is really becoming something I enjoy. So far the story has been good and the play control I really don't mind. I still think the menus are a bit strange, but nothing to complain about.

I am exploring around Undercity and it's been quite a bit of fun. I haven't purchased any items and you do seem to get enough stuff from drops and such, that said, I don't have a full set of armor yet.
Photo WhiteboySlim wrote on 02/10/2015 at 08:32pm
Canderous is cool as a character, but I don't think I've used him in any of my times through the game. Maybe I'll include him this time! Currently I'm heavily leaning towards Juhani and maybe T3 or Mission. Jolee is awesome too, but I've used him before. :D
Photo WhiteboySlim wrote on 02/10/2015 at 09:08pm
I don't remember where all the best gear comes from, but I do remember there are some shops on Dantooine with some nice stuff, but I think it is really expensive for you when you first get there, lol. Still, if you only use gear you find you should be pretty well equipped.
645df018407903293f2a9057b410a901.png?d=http%3a%2f%2fcheerfulghost.com%2fassets%2favatars%2fheadphone cheerful ghost vdogmr25 wrote on 02/10/2015 at 11:53pm
Tax return came through earlier than expected. Installing now. It's been a while since I've played so I'm gonna have trouble distinguishing between this and Kotor 2 until I get it installed and started.

I'm currently planning on Going scout for dual wield so I can use two sabers. I prefer 2 over the double blade as I can add different effects to each. HK-47 and Jolee were my go to party members. That may change this time, and I'm trying to approach this play through like I did the first time I played. Very little planned, adapt as I go. Next play through will be more about stat management and planning.
D954c245b9b17eb70ef2a7f547d392a9d148df97 full jdodson wrote on 02/11/2015 at 01:20am
I haven't allocated any stats yet. At what level do you start doing that?
645df018407903293f2a9057b410a901.png?d=http%3a%2f%2fcheerfulghost.com%2fassets%2favatars%2fheadphone cheerful ghost vdogmr25 wrote on 02/11/2015 at 02:02am
I misspoke. I meant feat allocation, and that is done differently by class. Stats auto upgrade with your class level. This might help: http://strategywiki.org/wiki/Star_Wars:_Knights_of_the_Old_Republic/Classes
Photo WhiteboySlim wrote on 02/11/2015 at 03:42am
Not to be confused with Attributes, like STR or DEX, which you do pick when you first make your character. You also gain one attribute point to distribute every few levels. :)
645df018407903293f2a9057b410a901.png?d=http%3a%2f%2fcheerfulghost.com%2fassets%2favatars%2fheadphone cheerful ghost vdogmr25 wrote on 02/11/2015 at 09:48pm
So I just remembered one of my favorite parts of this game. Near the beginning, there's a quest to get to the lower city of the first planet by either getting a sith armor set or by getting authorization papers. I just walked up to the guard, put my disguise on in front of him, and headed down. Not the brightest crayon, are you sith guard?
Photo WhiteboySlim wrote on 02/12/2015 at 12:43am
Look man, that Sith Trooper has a very simple job description: If they have the uniform or the proper papers, let 'em through. The Sith are not an organization known for treating their employees very well. He probably doesn't get paid enough to care. You got the uniform? Yeah, sure, go on through.
645df018407903293f2a9057b410a901.png?d=http%3a%2f%2fcheerfulghost.com%2fassets%2favatars%2fheadphone cheerful ghost vdogmr25 wrote on 02/12/2015 at 05:49am
Fair enough.
Photo WhiteboySlim wrote on 02/12/2015 at 05:56pm
So I wrapped up the Dantooine quest line last night and I'm able to travel to different planets now. First thing I noticed was a new space station orbiting Yavin that was not in my Xbox version! Looks like it's just a shop to sell high end equipment, which is cool. I looked the station up on-line and apparently you can get it for the Xbox version if you have an Xbox live account, which I never did. :P

Also, speaking of this new shop with all this expensive gear... I forgot how poor you are in this game if you want to go light side. Seriously, every light side option is like "no no, I don't need a reward!" or "Here poor person, take this money... plus an extra 200!" My Jedi is turning out more morally gray than I planned just because I want some damn money once in awhile.
Photo WhiteboySlim wrote on 02/19/2015 at 07:28pm
I didn't get to play much over the weekend, but I did jump on for a little bit last night and wrapped up Tattooine. I'm definitely becoming a more morally gray Jedi as I go. I still save hostages and (usually) pick the nice dialogue options, but there have been several times I've had the option of negotiating my way out of a fight, and decided it was a lot easier and more fun to just stab them in the face. Surprisingly this doesn't always earn me dark side points. :P

I'm curious how everyone else is progressing. Are you going light or dark? Do you have a preference on which order to do the planets?
645df018407903293f2a9057b410a901.png?d=http%3a%2f%2fcheerfulghost.com%2fassets%2favatars%2fheadphone cheerful ghost vdogmr25 wrote on 02/19/2015 at 10:42pm
I'm doing quests on Dantooine at the moment. Butbag McButts (yes that is my character name) has gone from a scout to a guardian. I'm going light side as usual, mostly because the light side powers get so cheap. Force heal for days!
Photo WhiteboySlim wrote on 02/20/2015 at 12:11am
Hey weird names fit the Star Wars universe. I mean there's a guy named Elan Sleazebaggano in the freakin' canon.

I know your team is probably limited at the moment since you're still on Dantooine, but who are you using for your other two characters? I've decided to keep Juhani, but I've rotated out the third member a couple times now.
645df018407903293f2a9057b410a901.png?d=http%3a%2f%2fcheerfulghost.com%2fassets%2favatars%2fheadphone cheerful ghost vdogmr25 wrote on 02/20/2015 at 05:30am
Juhani hasn't joined my party yet. On Dantooine, I've had Canderous and Bastila, but I'm going to put Mission in soon for her security abilities in the ruin. I think there's stuff there that security will help.
D954c245b9b17eb70ef2a7f547d392a9d148df97 full jdodson wrote on 02/20/2015 at 04:18pm
I just got the Wookee and Blue woman person and just got past the Rancor. So far I dig the game but it's hard balancing working on the site and publishing Rubicon and playing the game. I've really enjoyed the game so far, the turn based mechanics are fun and I don't find it as hard as I thought it would be.

That said, my Starcraft 2: Heart of the Swarm game I started before I began KoTOR is calling me back and that's a ton of fun.
Photo WhiteboySlim wrote on 02/22/2015 at 07:26pm
One thing that's nice about Kotor is you can save anywhere (assuming you remember to save often, lol). So it's actually pretty easy to pick up and play in short intervals. The quest journal isn't the best, but it's usually enough to jog your memory on what you were doing.

As far as my own progress goes, after Tatooine I decided to head to Kashyyyk. I wrapped up Kashyyyk pretty quick, but I think I that's partly because I accidentally skipped a few side quests in the process. Oops.

Jon: It's funny you mentioned Star Craft 2. I just ordered a pair of copies for me and the wife. :)
D954c245b9b17eb70ef2a7f547d392a9d148df97 full jdodson wrote on 02/22/2015 at 09:40pm
Wings of Liberty is pretty darn cool. The single player is well done and the multiplayer is great too. Did you just get Wings or Heart of the Swarm?
Photo WhiteboySlim wrote on 02/23/2015 at 06:23pm
We just got the base game (wings).
Headphone cheerful ghost dannytron wrote on 02/23/2015 at 11:08pm
I just entered the Sand People Enclave. 15 hours in. Still trying to decide where to head to next once I'm done with Tatooine.

A couple of thoughts on the different versions of this game. I bought the iPad version for kicks when it was on sale a while back. I'm sure it's no surprise that the controls are wonky and uncomfortable. Only played a couple of hours before I switched to the Xbox version. Xbox has always been my preferred version due to the use of a gamepad and being able to chill on the couch. But since I don't have an original Xbox anymore I had to play on 360 and the emulation is pretty buggy. Major frame rate issues especially during battles. After about 6 hours I had to call it quits and go with PC. I noticed some lag on PC but after turning the grass off in the graphics settings the frame rate is smooth.
Photo WhiteboySlim wrote on 02/24/2015 at 07:16pm
First off, welcome to the discussion Dannytron! Thanks for the input on the different versions, you win the "I tried 'em all" award for this game club session. grin
Right now I'm torn between which version I like better: Xbox or PC. If the PC version had native controller support it'd be a no brainer. Also I haven't experimented with Mods for the PC version so that could be a tipping point as well.
I picked Kashyyyk as my next planet because I knew there was a recruitable character there, so I picked it for purely practical reasons.

On a side note, the month is about to wrap up but it looks like a lot of people (myself included) still have a ways to go to finish up the game. I'm thinking I'm going to extend the event out another couple of weeks so everyone has more time to play through and discuss the game. Does that sound good to everyone?
D954c245b9b17eb70ef2a7f547d392a9d148df97 full jdodson wrote on 02/24/2015 at 10:09pm
I think extending the event is a good way to do. I am going to head back after I finish up Heart of the Swarm and would like to continue talking about it. smile
74c46166202d8f4ef1a74e511e278b05.png?d=http%3a%2f%2fcheerfulghost.com%2fassets%2favatars%2fheadphone cheerful ghost Travis wrote on 02/24/2015 at 10:31pm
I'm not playing it, but I have played it about halfway through and am enjoying hearing your experiences so yes, please extend the event for my entertainment. You are my dancing monkeys.
Photo WhiteboySlim wrote on 02/28/2015 at 08:46pm
Things have been busy at Castle Slim lately, so I haven't gotten to play much lately. I pretty much just landed on Manaan and started the questline to get into the sith camp. How's everyone else progressing?
83129b8368dc8a6e0a086346d52d45fd08c4576d full scrypt wrote on 03/02/2015 at 06:35pm
After finally getting the game working on my system, I put in a solid 5 hours without leaving Taris. But then I died during the invasion of the Black Vulkar base. It was the last fight, I think, in the garage, for the swoop bike flux-capacitor-thingy. I was momentarily depressed, because I forgot where my last save would take me (I think it was back in the sewers somewhere). So thankful for autosaves these days!

One thing that I really appreciate with this game, is the overall linearity of the quest directives. Contrasting that, I've been playing through Dragon Age Inquisition, off and on since January, and the story/stories there are so dense and plentiful, that it's difficult at times to keep it all together. It's one of the reasons I love the Dragon Age series, but KotOR lets you play within those story elements one chunk at a time. You can chose what planet you want to go to, but once you're there, your focus is specific to that area, which can be refreshing. I don't know if that makes sense. I guess, I (and I'm sure others are like this) get overwhelmed, sometimes, at the openness of some games. Where there is so much in the game that could be done, I'll spend hours with friends in GTA 4, trying to launch a car into space by means of a glitched piece of playground equipment.

I am impressed with how the gameplay and story have held up over time. It helps to imagine the graphics are on par with the Clone War animated series. Playing with keyboard and mouse is weird, but felt more and more natural after a few hours. My character is female, as they tend to be. Meryl Silverburgh, because it's the first name that came to mind. I am trying to play stealthily, though, so that gravity isn't entirely lost :).
Photo WhiteboySlim wrote on 03/02/2015 at 07:08pm
I know "linear" is kind of a bad word in gaming, but it's not always a bad thing. I agree with you that it's nice to have each planet kind of have it's own quest line with a beginning and an end. That was one thing that was kind of hard for me when playing something like Oblivion. I kept getting so side tracked running side quests that I never really advanced the main story, lol.

You said you're playing a stealth character, does that mean you went Scoundrel? I remember from a previous play through that later on your Sneak attack skill can help you lay down some huge damage numbers once you learn some force abilities that let you stun enemies, but that making it through Taris was pretty tough. How has your play-through been so far?
83129b8368dc8a6e0a086346d52d45fd08c4576d full scrypt wrote on 03/02/2015 at 08:35pm
I picked the Scout class, but have been building toward a more stealthier character. I haven't been very subtle in my movements, yet. Mostly run in hacking and slashing (preferring blades over blasters), with the occasional grenade (sooo stealthy!). I'm also trying to build my Persuade skill. I seem to remember that helping a lot when I first played the game.

What does everyone think of the camera controls, being locked to horizontal pan only? Do you find it beneficial at all to the combat, or general gameplay, sequences?
Photo WhiteboySlim wrote on 03/03/2015 at 09:59pm
Scout is what I picked too. I love the free implant feats you pick up, as some of the implants you get later in the game are really good. The camera controls are weird, but I've never felt like it hindered me in any way.

There's not a lot of reasons to use stealth on Taris unless you feel like avoiding combat, but that means you'll be missing out on a lot of XP. Persuade opens up a lot of dialogue options though, so the earlier you build that up the better.
D5d9a3b8d3e196c84da0672a7cec635f.png?d=http%3a%2f%2fcheerfulghost.com%2fassets%2favatars%2fheadphone cheerful ghost rettisawesome wrote on 03/05/2015 at 06:53pm
Awh man. I forgot how much I love the ending. Some of the mist epic dialogue of all time between you and malek. Still gives me that tingle. Haha It reminded me that this game is what made me love writing stories and putting story and character first in my game preferences.
Headphone cheerful ghost dannytron wrote on 03/06/2015 at 03:03am
I know what you mean, Rettisawesome. I just finished it a couple of days ago. The ending gets me every time I play this game. Did you go light or dark?
D5d9a3b8d3e196c84da0672a7cec635f.png?d=http%3a%2f%2fcheerfulghost.com%2fassets%2favatars%2fheadphone cheerful ghost rettisawesome wrote on 03/06/2015 at 03:58pm
haha. this time i just went straight light side. i've played through so many times that i flipped a coin... i even did a female so i could romance carth. thinking about blasting through kotor 2 now. despite how many times i've plyed that one. there are still a few different bits that i've missed.

also. this has reminded me how bummed i am that they scrapped kotor 3 to devote resources to the old republic.... and the storylines that they were hinting at were awesome! they get back to the story of the main character in kotor1 (kotor2 focuses on a different character the Jedi Exile) and i think was supposed to feature more of the other characters coming back. carth. canderous as mandalore. man. I was excited. probably one of the only games i would purchase on release day. i dont think there are any other games that mean more to me in terms of my development as a gamer and nerd. i always loved star wars. but this was my first taste of the EU. although i suppose i plaid outcast and jedi academy before this.but still.
D5d9a3b8d3e196c84da0672a7cec635f.png?d=http%3a%2f%2fcheerfulghost.com%2fassets%2favatars%2fheadphone cheerful ghost rettisawesome wrote on 03/06/2015 at 03:59pm
lol "plaid" obviously meant played.
Photo WhiteboySlim wrote on 03/08/2015 at 06:31pm
Dang, I'm lagging behind everyone now! I wrapped up Manaan so I only have Korriban left as far as the main planets go. I hate Manaan, so I kinda took a little time off before tackling it. Now that it's out of the way I am looking forward to wrapping up the game. :D I think I've settled on the team of Jolee and Juhani. I usually don't pick three Jedi characters, but we're kicking so much butt right now. :P Jolee loads up our team with buffs and Juhani and I just slaughter everything with Master Force Speed and Flurry.

We're a bit lacking in skills though. My character (I went scout > jedi sentinel) is the only one who is specializing in anything really. I took a modest bonus to Int, so I get 3 skill points each level up. I originally was leveling Awareness, Persuasion and Computer skill, but I ended up switching Computer Skill for Demolition so I could recover mines when I turn around and sell.
Photo WhiteboySlim wrote on 03/11/2015 at 07:02pm
I'm currently half way through the Leviathan, so, you know, I'm about to get the MIND BLOWING PLOT TWIST.

I didn't make much progress in the game last night. I mostly fiddled with this program I downloaded (Xpadder) to map keyboard and mouse input to a controller. It actually worked really well! I still need to tweak the settings to get everything working.
74c46166202d8f4ef1a74e511e278b05.png?d=http%3a%2f%2fcheerfulghost.com%2fassets%2favatars%2fheadphone cheerful ghost Travis wrote on 03/11/2015 at 07:13pm
Xpadder is great for games where it works. Oblivion was released for Xbox 360 and PS3, yet the PC version has no gamepad support, and Xpadder doesn't work well at all for it. It's maddening. I mean yes, I prefer the keyboard and mouse, but sometimes you just want to lean back and play.
Photo WhiteboySlim wrote on 03/12/2015 at 05:34pm
Well our first official games club is about to wrap up. While I'm not sure I'll finish the game by the 14th, it seems like everyone else is probably done with the game so I'm going to let the event officially conclude, unless there are any objections. :)

What did everyone think of the Games Club? Is this something you'd like to see more of?
D5d9a3b8d3e196c84da0672a7cec635f.png?d=http%3a%2f%2fcheerfulghost.com%2fassets%2favatars%2fheadphone cheerful ghost rettisawesome wrote on 03/12/2015 at 10:58pm
I liked it. Although I didn't participate much. Gave me a reason to play a great game again. And talk about it.

What game were you thinking of next if you do again?
Photo WhiteboySlim wrote on 03/12/2015 at 11:21pm
I'm not sure. Any suggestions?

I plan on playing through Kotor 2 on my own after I finish up this one, but I don't know if I want to make the next Game Club game another RPG. One game I was considering was The Last of Of Us. I kind of want something that's multi-platform and has been out for awhile so that as many people as possible can play along.
D5d9a3b8d3e196c84da0672a7cec635f.png?d=http%3a%2f%2fcheerfulghost.com%2fassets%2favatars%2fheadphone cheerful ghost rettisawesome wrote on 03/12/2015 at 11:39pm
Last of us is good. I just finished that one a few weeks ago for the first time. Was pretty bummed at first about the linear storyline. But I realized I finished the whole game before I thought about it once. So kind of a moot point.

I'd have to think of some non RPG ideas.
74c46166202d8f4ef1a74e511e278b05.png?d=http%3a%2f%2fcheerfulghost.com%2fassets%2favatars%2fheadphone cheerful ghost Travis wrote on 03/13/2015 at 03:10am
I could definitely do Last Of Us. I started it but only got a short way through it before getting distracted by something else.
D954c245b9b17eb70ef2a7f547d392a9d148df97 full jdodson wrote on 03/13/2015 at 04:17am
Not sure what i'd recommend for a next game. I have been pretty busy working on the site and as such haven't had a ton of time for any serious gaming beyond a handful of Issac.

That said, reading and taking part in this game club has been fun. I'll lurk for the next one, whichever you do. smile

KoTOR is a really great game, I can see why it's on so many peoples best of lists.
83129b8368dc8a6e0a086346d52d45fd08c4576d full scrypt wrote on 03/14/2015 at 05:34pm
I'm in the same boat as @rettisawesome. I love this idea, even though I didn't participate much.

Last of Us would be cool. Never finished that one, either. Other games I'd vote for:

Dishonored
Legend of Grimmrock
Warhammer 40K: Space Marine
Myst
Beyond Good & Evil
Mirror's Edge
Papers, Please
Remember Me
Ico

Or something along those lines ;)
83129b8368dc8a6e0a086346d52d45fd08c4576d full scrypt wrote on 03/14/2015 at 06:43pm
It would be cool if we could play something that's new to everyone. Maybe come up with a short list to last us a few months/cycles? Can we do a poll on the site?
D5d9a3b8d3e196c84da0672a7cec635f.png?d=http%3a%2f%2fcheerfulghost.com%2fassets%2favatars%2fheadphone cheerful ghost rettisawesome wrote on 03/14/2015 at 06:48pm
I thought of beyond good and evil as well. Such a great game.
Here's some I've thought of.

Shadow of the colossus
Freelancer
Gothic
Half life 2
Hitman blood money
Mark of the ninja
Mass effect
Mount and blade warband
Nexus the Jupiter incidebt
Morrowind (probably my first pick. But trying not to be lame)
The wolf among us
Company of heroes
Warhammer 40k dawn of war
Any metal gear solid

A huge unhelpful list. But all games are great. And a joy to play when you have others to talk about it with. Also a variety of genre.

I can answer any questions about any of them if someone needs.
D5d9a3b8d3e196c84da0672a7cec635f.png?d=http%3a%2f%2fcheerfulghost.com%2fassets%2favatars%2fheadphone cheerful ghost rettisawesome wrote on 03/14/2015 at 06:49pm
Dawn of war 2 is what I meant.
Photo WhiteboySlim wrote on 03/14/2015 at 07:03pm
Sounds like Last of Us would be a good pick, based on everyone's comments. I also like the idea of Half-life 2, since that's one I own but haven't played yet. :P

Papers, Please could be a great conversation piece.

I think I know why Morrowind is your first pick, Rett. :P That would be pretty convienent for you, I don't blame you for recommending that, lol. P.S. Did you want to post about your play-through on CG? I bet the community would find that interesting too. Morrowind might be a little too big for something like this. I briefly considered Skyrim. It's not a requirement that everyone (or even anyone) complete the game we're playing for the games club, but it would be nice if it's at lest possible to finish in a month or two, lol.

I've heard a lot of great things about Beyond Good and Evil, I'd be open to that. It's on GOG.com for $10, so that's not bad. I'd be open to that.

I know Jon has posted polls on here before. I'll ask him about setting up something. In the mean time keep posting suggestions!
D5d9a3b8d3e196c84da0672a7cec635f.png?d=http%3a%2f%2fcheerfulghost.com%2fassets%2favatars%2fheadphone cheerful ghost rettisawesome wrote on 03/14/2015 at 11:58pm
lol yeah tim. well this whole thing i got in the works with morrowind has just really rekindled my passion for that game. and i've been playing it a ton recently to get into the right headspace. it really is the best in the elder scrolls series. and i love talking to people who are just sort of tapping into its wealth of gameplay for the first time. or at least coming to understand its depth for the first time. i love skyrim. and have logged more hours in oblivion than any other game. but morrowind.... man! so great. and wiith the trove of mods out for it now. the gameplay never ends.

and yeah i think i will probably make some posts here about our play throughs and all that stuff when the time comes. things are still coming downt he pipes. im trying to convice my buddy lee to make an account over here too. but he doesnt even have a facebook. so its like herding cats.

i think hl2 would be a great choice. there is a reason that it is one of the best games from the previous decade. and does not take long to complete.

but idk.
D954c245b9b17eb70ef2a7f547d392a9d148df97 full jdodson wrote on 03/15/2015 at 02:02am
Half-life 2? Speaking if games I totally want to replay. I had a friend that went through it recently and he said it was just as strong now as it was.
74c46166202d8f4ef1a74e511e278b05.png?d=http%3a%2f%2fcheerfulghost.com%2fassets%2favatars%2fheadphone cheerful ghost Travis wrote on 03/15/2015 at 04:11am
I"m casting my vote for HL2. It isn't new to me, not by a long shot. I've probably played it 5 times, most recently last year, maybe? But I'd love to replay it.
83129b8368dc8a6e0a086346d52d45fd08c4576d full scrypt wrote on 03/15/2015 at 05:15am
So far the rising titles seem to be:

Last of Us
Half-Life 2
Beyond Good & Evil

I'd love to go back and play Mass Effect again. Such a great game. Shadow of the Colossus is one of those that I never finished, but desperately need to.

Any of these work for me. What if we narrow the list to 3-5 games, poll it, and see who comes out victorious?
74c46166202d8f4ef1a74e511e278b05.png?d=http%3a%2f%2fcheerfulghost.com%2fassets%2favatars%2fheadphone cheerful ghost Travis wrote on 03/15/2015 at 05:29am
Or if we're all in agreement on those three, just draw lots for which goes first and we have the year planned out! :)
74c46166202d8f4ef1a74e511e278b05.png?d=http%3a%2f%2fcheerfulghost.com%2fassets%2favatars%2fheadphone cheerful ghost Travis wrote on 03/15/2015 at 05:30am
Five. Those five.
Photo WhiteboySlim wrote on 03/15/2015 at 05:45pm
I started Mass Effect but didn't get very far. That might be a good pick later on down the line, for this next game I'm leaning towards not picking another RPG just to add some variety. If the games club becomes a regular thing, there will be plenty of RPG's we'll go through just because, as a genre, I feel like RPG's are kind of perfect for an event like this.

I've been wanting to play Shadow of the Colossus for awhile now. I'd be ok putting that on the poll.
D5d9a3b8d3e196c84da0672a7cec635f.png?d=http%3a%2f%2fcheerfulghost.com%2fassets%2favatars%2fheadphone cheerful ghost rettisawesome wrote on 03/15/2015 at 07:30pm
Sotc would be my vote first then. Got the ps3 redux so sweet. Probably in my top 5. So perfect. Beaten it no joke 20 times. Cuz I heard about this secret garden that you need to beat and repeat several times to get your grip meter big enough to climb there.... Still haven't .

But I would love to see the little things people discover. Maybe compare time trials stuff etc. Would be fun
83129b8368dc8a6e0a086346d52d45fd08c4576d full scrypt wrote on 03/15/2015 at 10:32pm
Sweet. So, let's go with these four:

Last of Us
Shadow of the Colossus
Half-Life 2
Beyond Good & Evil

If we want to only pick the next game, head to this link and vote! http://goo.gl/qO87UO

If we want to rank these and set the next 4 games for the year, I'll volunteer to sort. Private message me here on the site with your list ranking the above games from 1-4, 1 being your first pick, etc. I can tally and sort, and post results below.
83129b8368dc8a6e0a086346d52d45fd08c4576d full scrypt wrote on 03/15/2015 at 10:40pm
Or, I suppose you could just post your picks in order here in the comments, if we want to be all open about it ;)
D954c245b9b17eb70ef2a7f547d392a9d148df97 full jdodson wrote on 03/15/2015 at 10:54pm
Voted
83129b8368dc8a6e0a086346d52d45fd08c4576d full scrypt wrote on 03/16/2015 at 04:09pm
Last of Us and Half-Life 2 are neck and neck. Are @vdogmr25 and @dannytron still with us?
Photo WhiteboySlim wrote on 03/17/2015 at 03:42am
Dannytron is around here somewhere. I'll text him and tell him to come vote.

I'm thinking we should also make a post on the main page and see if anyone else wants to vote for the next game too.
Headphone cheerful ghost dannytron wrote on 03/17/2015 at 10:05pm
I vote for Half-LIfe 2. It's been a while since I last played.
83129b8368dc8a6e0a086346d52d45fd08c4576d full scrypt wrote on 03/18/2015 at 03:09am
Give me a second, I'll post on the main page.
If you want to join this conversation you need to sign in.
Sign Up / Log In
Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.
© 2016 Cheerful Ghost LLC. All rights reserved. Cheerful Ghost and the Ghost Logo are registered trademarks of Cheerful Ghost LLC.